“Murder in the Dark” is a chilling tale that throws a washed-up singer, Danny Sierra, and his fractured family together in a remote cottage under unsettling circumstances. The play boasts an excellent set and lighting design, effectively creating distinct atmospheres, from warm sing-alongs to spine-tingling ghostly encounters. These elements truly elevate the production.
However, the narrative stumbles at times. The writer attempts to weave in several classic ghost story tropes, leading to a sense of confusion and over-stuffed plot. Questions pile up – is it real, is it in Danny’s head, who is the mysterious old woman? While these elements hold potential, their sheer volume creates a feeling of trying to squeeze too much into the story.
The acting performances also contribute to the mixed experience. The production occasionally shifts between tones, feeling like a thriller one moment and a pantomime the next. While there are genuinely funny and creepy moments, their juxtaposition feels jarring and disrupts the flow of suspense.
Despite the shortcomings, “Murder in the Dark” holds some appeal. The show is worth considering if you enjoy a moderately creepy atmosphere, and as mentioned, the set and lighting deserve praise. Special recognition goes to the performances of Owen Oakeshott and Susie Blake.
Overall, “Murder in the Dark” is a production with intriguing elements but hampered by a convoluted story and inconsistent tonal shifts. It lands at a solid 3 stars, offering a decent experience for those seeking a mildly spooky night out, but not quite reaching its full potential.
Murder in the Dark is at the Everyman Theatre Cheltenham until March 9th
