HOT
Entertainment Now
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Comedy
  • Music
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Theatre
  • Lifestyle
  • Podcasts
  • Edinburgh Festivals
Entertainment Now
No Result
View All Result
Home Comedy

Edfringe Comedy Review: Tom Rosenthal: Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I Am

Teddy Jamieson by Teddy Jamieson
August 4, 2025
in Comedy, Edinburgh Festivals
23 2
0
Edfringe Comedy Review: Tom Rosenthal: Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I Am
25
SHARES
1.2k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
dolly parton

Come on, this is your chance, Tom Rosenthal tells us right at the beginning. Your chance, he says, to say “shalom” to him, or “this is a lovely bit of squirrel,” or, if Plebs is your preferred sitcom over Friday Night Dinner (maybe there are two people in the world who are of that opinion), “Salve, Marcus”.

It’s an opportunity, in short, to get all those kneejerk reactions out of the way and to establish the fact that Rosenthal knows what he is known for; that if you’re here to see him do stand-up it might have something to do with the fact that you know him from the two successful sitcoms he starred in back in the 2010s.

Although, actually, sometimes that’s not the case. There’s someone in the front row tonight – been dragged along by a friend – who doesn’t know who he is. Which, in a way, perfectly speaks to Rosenthal’s point. That he is aware that he is at best a minor celebrity.

He’s also aware that there are some people who will prefer that “early stuff” he did. After all, he loves the Arctic Monkeys, but only the first two albums.

Which is why he has come tonight dressed up as the band’s front man Alex Turner; hair slicked back, chain around his neck, big trousers.

This is a show about perceptions, identity and why artists and performers have to keep changing – unless you’re Oasis, I suppose – even when we don’t want them to.

That said, it’s quite a light scaffold for a show, I’d say. And that turns out to have advantages and disadvantages. It certainly allows him a real freedom to skip between physical and verbal comedy, to jump the tracks when it suits, and generally amuse himself and us. But it does run the risk of not really hanging together as a coherent entity.
There are worse things, though. From minute to minute, Rosenthal’s material is funny, waspish (David Baddiel comes in for some stick; for good reason as Rosenthal explains), even daring. It makes for a good Friday night out. Or Saturday, or Sunday, or …

So what’s the takeaway? That there’s plenty to enjoy here, even if you think that, actually, Tranquility Base Hotel and Casino is, in fact, the Arctic Monkey’s best album.

Tom Rosenthal: Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I Am, Assembly Roxy, 18.15, until August 24

Tags: reviews
Teddy Jamieson

Teddy Jamieson

Teddy Jamieson has been driven around Los Angeles by a former Sex Pistol, been in bed with Joss Stone and spoken to comedians ranging from Frank Carson to Frank Skinner (even a few not called Frank). He has been writing about the arts for The Herald for more than 20 years.

Trending

Why a Guided Tour of Seville Cathedral Is Worth It
Lifestyle

Why a Guided Tour of Seville Cathedral Is Worth It

2 weeks ago
Starstruck with Sam Newman Drops First episode
Podcasts

Starstruck with Sam Newman Drops First episode

2 weeks ago
Planetary x Impressive Is Alt Escape’s Must-See All-Day Showcase
Music

Planetary x Impressive Is Alt Escape’s Must-See All-Day Showcase

1 day ago
Review: SXSW 2026
Music

Review: SXSW 2026

2 weeks ago
Review: The Constant Wife – Everyman Theatre, Cheltenham
Theatre

Review: The Constant Wife – Everyman Theatre, Cheltenham

1 day ago
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Comedy
  • Music
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Theatre
  • Lifestyle
  • Podcasts
  • Edinburgh Festivals